Home / Construction / What the Fama Case Shows General Contractors About OSHA’s Controlling Employer Duty

What the Fama Case Shows General Contractors About OSHA’s Controlling Employer Duty

The Eleventh Circuit let OSHA’s citations against Fama stand in 2026. Learn what counts as reasonable care and the records that prove GC oversight.

Table of Contents

What the Fama Case Shows General Contractors About OSHA’s Controlling Employer Duty

Key Takeaways

  • Fama Construction stopped inspecting jobsites and training its roofing crews, and the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) still cited it for those crews’ fall protection and hard hat violations. The Eleventh Circuit let the citations stand in February 2026.
  • OSHA treats an employer as a controlling employer when it has authority to correct hazards or make others correct them, whether that authority comes from a contract or from how the company runs the site.
  • A controlling employer’s duty is lighter than its duty to its own employees, and it scales with the project and each subcontractor’s safety history.
  • OSHA’s directive judges reasonable care through questions that each leave a paper trail, from inspection frequency to how a general contractor enforces its rules.

An OSHA inspector drove past a townhome development in Dawsonville, Georgia, in March 2019 and saw a roofer moving shingle packets with no fall protection. A second worker was running a shingle elevator on the ground without a hard hat. Both belonged to roofing crews that Fama Construction subcontracted, and Fama had used those crews for more than a decade.

OSHA cited Fama anyway. The company had stopped auditing its jobsites and training its crews by then, on the position that safety belonged to the subcontractors. Fama fought the citations for nearly seven years, and the Eleventh Circuit denied its petition in February 2026, leaving the citations in place.

The case shows how OSHA decides who counts as a controlling employer and how much oversight that role requires. It also shows what can happen when a company that controls a site steps back from subcontractor safety altogether.

What Happened in the Fama Case

Fama’s history with OSHA started well before 2019. The agency had inspected Fama worksites at least seven times since 2013 and issued a fall protection violation each time, according to the Eleventh Circuit’s opinion. Fama resolved some earlier citations through settlements in which it agreed to improve worker safety and inspect its projects more often.

Fama had gone the other direction by 2019. A company representative told OSHA that Fama no longer audited its sites or trained its crews, based on legal advice that inspections and training could look like evidence of an employment relationship with the roofers, according to the administrative law judge’s decision on remand. That concern can matter for companies that rely on subcontracted crews, and Fama’s case shows a hands-off approach brings exposure of its own.

DateWhat happened
2013 to 2019OSHA inspects Fama worksites at least seven times and issues a fall protection violation each time
March 2019An inspector sees Fama’s subcontracted roofers working without fall protection or hard hats, and OSHA cites Fama for missing jobsite inspections, missing hard hats, and a repeat fall protection violation
March 2023The Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission agrees Fama is a controlling employer but sends the case back, because the judge had held Fama to the stricter duty an employer owes its own workers
April 2023The judge rules for OSHA again under the correct standard and assesses $68,344 in penalties
February 2026The Eleventh Circuit denies Fama’s petition, and the citations stand

Fama’s appeal rested on two lines of argument. Fama challenged the multi-employer policy itself, but the court declined to review those challenges because Fama hadn’t properly raised them before the Commission. Fama also argued that compliance was economically infeasible, since enforcing fall protection would require a $50,000-a-year supervisor, a cost it said would exceed its annual profits.

The court rejected the infeasibility defense. Fama offered no evidence that a full-time supervisor was the only way to comply, and it took no alternative steps to protect the crews, even though it knew they had broken the same rules before.

Why Fama Counted as a Controlling Employer

OSHA’s Multi-Employer Citation Policy defines a controlling employer as one with general supervisory authority over the worksite, including the power to correct safety and health violations or require others to correct them. That authority can come from a contract or from how a company actually runs the job, even when the contract says nothing about safety.

Fama’s owners admitted in depositions that they had authority to stop unsafe work and remove roofers from the jobsite. The judge found that admission enough to make Fama a controlling employer. Fama argued the label fit a general contractor better than a company in its position, and the Commission upheld the finding anyway.

The directive’s own examples point the same way for general contractors. A construction manager can count as a controlling employer even when its contract denies it authority over safety, as long as its other rights necessarily affect safety. The directive calls out schedule setting, construction sequencing, and dispute resolution between subcontractors as especially significant. A contract clause that assigns safety to subcontractors tends to carry little weight when the general contractor still decides which crews work where, and when.

The policy does have limits. The directive describes an architect who points out hazards but has no means to enforce anything, and it concludes that firm isn’t a controlling employer, since it had no authority to make anyone fix what it reported.

What Reasonable Care Means for a Controlling Employer

A controlling employer must exercise reasonable care to prevent and detect violations, and OSHA sets that bar lower than the duty an employer owes its own workers. The directive says OSHA doesn’t normally expect a controlling employer to inspect as often as the subcontractor or to match its trade expertise. That distinction mattered in Fama, since the Commission sent the case back once because the judge had applied the stricter standard.

The directive lists the factors that set how often and how closely a controlling employer should inspect:

  • The scale of the project
  • The nature and pace of the work, including how often the number or types of hazards change as the work progresses
  • What the controlling employer knows about each subcontractor’s safety history, safety practices, and level of expertise

Safety history can push inspection frequency either way. A known record of non-compliance calls for more frequent inspections, and so does a subcontractor the general contractor has never worked with, especially early in the project. A consistently high level of compliance can justify fewer inspections, and the directive names it as the most important sign that a subcontractor’s own safety effort works.

Fama lost under the correct standard too. The judge weighed roofing work that exposed crews to falls, an exclusive roofing contract for the whole development, and a record of fall protection violations at Fama sites, some involving the same crews. Those facts called for more frequent inspections than usual, and Fama had stopped inspecting entirely.

The directive then frames reasonable care around three questions. Inspectors consider whether the controlling employer:

  1. Conducted periodic inspections at an appropriate frequency
  2. Implemented an effective system for promptly correcting hazards
  3. Enforced subcontractor compliance through an effective, graduated system of enforcement and follow-up inspections

One example in the directive shows how a general contractor can handle the first question well and still fall short on the third. The general contractor inspects often enough, finds fall protection violations by a painting subcontractor, and points them out each time. It takes no further action, and the directive concludes a citation is appropriate because the contractor lacked a graduated system of enforcement.

What a Defensible Oversight Record Contains

Many general contractors already produce records that can answer each of the directive’s three questions. The gaps tend to show up in how those records connect, such as an observation that never links to its fix or a repeat violation that never leads to a next step.

Directive questionRecords that can answer it
Inspections at an appropriate frequencyDated site walks and observations, plus a note on why that frequency fits the project and each subcontractor’s history
A system for promptly correcting hazardsCorrective actions tied to the original observation, with an owner and a close-out time stamp
Graduated enforcement and follow-upA subcontractor-level history showing warnings, escalation steps, and follow-up inspections when the same problem repeats

The directive also suggests a subcontractor’s own paperwork can count toward a controlling employer’s oversight. One example describes a host employer that monitored its contractor through weekly inspections, phone check-ins, and a weekly review of the contractor’s own inspection reports. That monitoring met the reasonable care standard, alongside a graduated enforcement system and the contractor’s strong compliance record.

Daily pre-task plans (PTPs), observations, and near-miss reports from subcontractor crews can fill a similar role on a larger site, as long as someone reviews them and acts on what they show. Signed forms that nobody reviews tend to show only that the paperwork exists, which does little to demonstrate oversight.

Fama’s infeasibility argument adds one more lesson. The court didn’t accept that oversight required a $50,000 supervisor, because Fama offered no evidence that lower-cost alternatives would fall short. A general contractor that later argues oversight was too expensive could face the same question about what else it tried.

Turning Frontline Data Into an Oversight Record

Frontline data can help a general contractor answer each of the directive’s questions, provided it arrives consistently from every trade and gets sorted fast enough to act on. Here’s what that can look like in practice, using Safety Mojo as an example.

Setting inspection frequency by subcontractor. The directive ties inspection frequency to what a general contractor knows about each subcontractor’s history. Safety Mojo’s Contractor Scorecard gives each trade a current safety score built on leading and lagging indicators. A safety manager can use that comparison to decide which crews need closer attention, and the scores help document the reasoning behind the inspection schedule.

Deciding where to look first. Safety Mojo’s Risk Feed Dashboard reviews roughly the last 10 days of safety submissions, including PTPs, observations, permit requests, and incident and near-miss reports, then lists the items that most need attention. It ranks each item by hazard severity under OSHA standards, recent activity on that job, and priorities the safety team sets, and it explains why the item made the list. An unprotected edge on an elevated deck would rank well above a housekeeping issue, which points a superintendent toward the fall hazard first.

Closing the loop. A superintendent who fixes a flagged hazard and logs the corrective action in Safety Mojo creates a time-stamped record tied to the original submission. Risk Feed shows existing corrective actions alongside flagged items, so the safety team can see which hazards still lack a fix.

Knowing when to escalate. A trade that keeps showing up in Risk Feed, or whose Contractor Scorecard keeps slipping, gives the safety team a documented reason to move to the next step in its enforcement policy. The steps themselves come from the general contractor’s own policy, and the record shows when each one happened.

The ranking depends on what crews submit, so submission quality matters too. Safety Mojo’s Flex PTP reads pre-task plans and permit requests in the formats crews already use, including paper, whiteboards, PDFs, and voice, and scores each one against a rubric the safety team sets. Conversational Forms lets workers report observations and incidents by talking, in English or Spanish.

That chain of records can show when the general contractor learned of a hazard and how quickly it acted, which matters most if OSHA shows up after an incident.

Where Fama Leaves General Contractors

Fama didn’t settle any open questions about the multi-employer policy, since the court never reached them. The case still shows how OSHA and the Commission apply the policy today, including what happens when a company with authority over a site does nothing to oversee it.

General contractors weighing how closely to direct subcontracted crews may want to talk with counsel about both sides of that line, since Fama’s retreat from oversight started with legal advice. A consistent record of inspections and follow-through gives a general contractor something concrete to show when OSHA or an insurer asks what it did about a hazard.

Our ebook, How AI Turns Frontline Safety Data Into the Actions That Reduce Incidents, walks through how Risk Feed builds a ranked list of actions from each day’s submissions. Download the ebook to learn more.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a controlling employer under OSHA?

A controlling employer has general supervisory authority over a worksite, including the power to correct safety and health violations or require others to correct them. That authority can come from a contract or from how the company runs the site in practice.

Can OSHA cite a general contractor for a subcontractor’s safety violation?

Yes. OSHA’s Multi-Employer Citation Policy lets the agency cite a general contractor that controls the site for hazards affecting subcontractor workers, if the contractor failed to exercise reasonable care to prevent and detect violations.

What did the Eleventh Circuit decide in the Fama case?

The court denied Fama Construction’s petition in February 2026 and left OSHA’s citations in place. It declined to review Fama’s challenges to the multi-employer policy because Fama hadn’t properly raised them before the Review Commission, and it rejected Fama’s argument that compliance was economically infeasible.

What is a graduated system of enforcement?

It’s a set of escalating responses when a subcontractor repeats a safety violation, which might run from a verbal warning to a written notice to removal from the site. OSHA’s directive names it as one factor in judging whether a controlling employer exercised reasonable care.

Picture of Sam Bigelow

Sam Bigelow

Sam Bigelow is the Content Marketing Manager at Safety Mojo, where he writes about construction safety, jobsite technology, and the field realities of large commercial and data center builds. A former journalist, he has spent more than five years covering technology and blue-collar industries, including construction.

See Safety Mojo in Action

Schedule a quick demo of Safety Mojo to learn how easy it is to boost compliance and reduce risk on any project.

A Smart Safety Platform for Complex Construction Projects

Safety Mojo gives you a complete view of frontline safety, risk, and compliance.

Book Your Personalized Demo

Let's Get Started

Send us a message and we`ll respond as soon as possible

“*” indicates required fields